As described by James Wood in How Fiction Works, the flaneur is
the loafer, usually a young man, who walks the streets with no great urgency, seeing, looking, reflecting.
Flânerie describes aimless behaviour. In French it’s spelt like this: flâneur.
Wood also uses the great phrases ‘porous scout‘ and ‘Noah’s dove‘ to describe this authorial stand-in. These characters are focalisers.
A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE FLANEUR
The Flaneur comes straight out of Romantic poetry. The poet of Wordsworth’s Prelude (began in 1798) is the classic Romantic Flaneur. Poet Charles Baudelaire (1821–1867) also created Flaneurs in his poetry.
These guys are extroverts who live in the moment and are best suited to city life. However, they interact with a city without ever really being a part of it. They feel themselves to be outsiders.
The Flaneur is a wandering narrator who is at once an outsider and native to a particular urban environment.
The flaneur hangs around cities because there’s not so much for him to do in the country. You won’t find Jane Austen’s characters wandering around aimlessly. But these guys aren’t truly aimless: they wander around with the purpose of deconstructing social life in order to form a critique.
Walter Benjamin (1892-1940) drew on the poetry of Baudelaire and created even more Flaneurs, bringing the Flaneur to the attention of literary critics.
The Flaneur was born again. We see an updated Flaneur in Rilke’s autobiographical novel The Notebooks of Malte Laurids Briggs by Rainer Maria Rilke (1910), in Nausea by Jean-Paul Sartre (1938) and in Mrs Dalloway by Virginia Woolf (1925).
THE FLANEUR IS DIFFICULT TO WRITE
If you’re writing a Flaneur main character the story will be propelled forward mainly by writerly brilliance. Descriptions must be amazing.
The raison d’etre of the flaneur novel is to allow the writer to have a say about something, so entire novels written in this style tend to become a series of essays and these will vary in quality. The flaneur story is perhaps better suited to short stories.
THE FLANEUR IS HIGHLY SENSITIVE
James Wood also uses the term ‘overloaded flaneur’. He offers the examples of Salman Rushdie’s novel Fury (2001) and the titular character from Herzog, a 1964 novel by Saul Bellow.
A man goes out to record, with all the writer’s fineness of observation on his side, what the writer would have seen were the writer able to speak autobiographically, like the ‘I’ of a Romantic poem.The Irresponsible Self: On Laughter and the Novel
This ‘too-porous scout’ suffers from sensory overload. He suffers because of his sensitivity. He has also lost his way.
The old maps have gone, and the new signs are unreadable; and so the modern flaneur is driven mad by the indecipherable abundance of contemporary signification.
THE FLANEUR IN CHILDREN’S LITERATURE
Middle Grade Novels
Since the flaneur loves busy, interesting cities like New York, some critics have made a subcategory of American children’s literature set in New York where we might find the children’s literature version of the flaneur. Eric L. Tribunella finds the flaneur in:
- The Saturdays by Elizabeth Enright (1941)
- Harriet the Spy by Louise Fitzhugh (1964)
- From the Mixed-up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler by E.L. Konigsburg (1967)
- The Planet of Junior Brown by Virginia Hamilton (1971)
Although Tribunella published that paper in 2010, he cites examples from the Second Golden Age of Children’s Literature, which started after WW2 and ended around 1970.
Do modern young audiences have any time for the flaneur? When it comes to picture books, there is a subcategory designed to take the reader through a city, as an armchair tourist. Some critics have said that this is the picture book version of the flaneur, in which the reader is the flaneur, not necessarily a character inside the story. Again, look out for American picture books, particularly those set in New York or Los Angeles.
Young Adult Novels
In modern teen fiction, consider the mall instead of the city as a place where young flaneur hang out.
In stories where teens hang out in malls — and often in real life too — teens are not welcome. The mall has the feeling of a safe, cloistered space and mall designers go out of their way to make shoppers feel as comfortable as if they were at home: modern malls are carpeted and warm and play calming music. Comfortable big furniture is provided as islands of refuge. Yet when teenagers congregate in malls they are not genuinely welcome unless they happen to have the disposable income of adults. Therefore, the mall in young adult literature is a setting which functions as a symbol of teenage-hood itself: that liminal space between childhood and adulthood.
THE POSTMODERN FLANEUR
Weetzie-Bat (1989), the debut punk-rock fairytale novel by Francesca Lia Block features a narrator who is both part of her urban environment but also narrates as if she’s an outsider. This archetype has been called a post-modern flaneur.
By this interpretation, the flaneur in children’s literature is unlikely to go away, since the entire category of young adult literature makes heavy use of that feeling of being an outsider trying to find your place.
AVOID WRITING ACCIDENTAL FLANEURS
[W]hen I first started writing fiction in my late teens it didn’t occur to me that there was no plot in them and people just wandered around. I literally had these little “plot” cards for when I got tired of the people just sitting around and talking, and they were stuff like, “The cart falls off a cliff,” and “someone dies.” Sure, those are things that happen, but they are not character-driven plot.Kameron Hurley, on her own writing evolution
Coddiwomple: To travel purposefully toward an as-yet-unknown destination. (English slang)
- For more examples of young adult novels with a flaneur quality, see The Flaneur Goes To The Mall at The Millions
- A variation on the Flaneur archetype in storytelling is the Sunday Wanderer. This is a character who wanders around leisurely making observations about their surroundings. It comes from an earlier era in Judeo-Christian countries when Sundays really were for doing nothing. But the Sunday Wanderer doesn’t have to be wandering on a Sunday. In literature, Katherine Mansfield’s Miss Brill is an excellent example of the Sunday Wanderer. Unlike the Flaneur, The Sunday Wanderer is neither associated with masculinity nor urban settings.
WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A FLANEUR AND A DANDY?
If we stick to Baudelaire’s depictions, the dandy is sort of the introverted version of a flaneur. Dandies don’t enjoy being in the limelight. They groom nicely because they are self-conscious about how they come across to others, not because they wish to be noticed.
However, in actual usage, speakers and writers don’t necessarily draw a distinction between a flaneur and a dandy. Take the 1821 publication The dandy’s perambulations: embellished with sixteen caricature engravings by Robert Cruickshank. Decide for yourself if he describes a flaneur or a dandy by Baudelaire’s definition.
Header painting: Atkinson Grimshaw – Tree Shadows on the Park Wall, Roundhay Park, Leeds