The Centrality Of The Adventure Story

The story of the hero and his quest, the adventure story, is always essentially the same. It is the story of Odysseus, of Jason and the Golden Fleece, of Beowulf, of Saint George, of the Knights of the Round Table, of Jack and the Beanstalk, of Robinson Crusoe, of Peter Rabbit, of James Bond, of Luke Skywalker, of Batman, of Indiana Jones, of the latest sci-fi adventure and the latest game in the computer shop. It appears in countless legends, folk tales, children’s stories and adult thrillers. It is ubiquitous. Northrop Frye has argued that the quest myth is the basic myth of all literature, deriving its meanings from the cycle of the seasons and ‘the central expression of human meanings from the cycle of the seasons and ‘the central expression of human energy [which transformed] the amorphous natural environment into the pastoral, cultivated, civilized world of human shape and meaningthe hero is the reviving power of spring and the monster and old king and outgrown forces of apathy and impotence in a symbolic winter.’ Whether we accept this or not, the centrality of the hero story in our culture is unarguable.

– Margery Hourihan, Deconstructing The Hero

bfd54bcbd830e4f814a2a3588b248289

 


 

NINETEENTH-CENTURY ADVENTURES

ivanhoe-scott Robinson Crusoe cover

Examples

British

  • Robinson Crusoe (by Daniel Defoe, though not written specifically for children, filtered through to the classroom). Gave rise to the term ‘Robinsonnades’.
  • Swiss Family Robinson (by J.D. Wyss, introduced into England in 1814)
  • Masterman Ready, Settlers in Canada, Children of the New Forest, The Little Savage (written by a Captain Marryat, who didn’t think much of Wyss’s geography or seamanship. His stories were the first to be written specifically for children. He’d had a vivid career at sea. His books are heavily didactic.)
  • English Family Robinson (by Mayne Reid)
  • Mark’s Reef (by Fenimore Cooper)
  • The Coral Island (by R.M. Ballantyne. Ballantyne the brave was born Edinburgh 1825 and spent his 20s working in Canada for the Hudson’s Bay Company. He wrote his first adult book while stationed at one of the loneliest outposts there, while in charge of one Indian and a horse. The mail came twice per year. He published The Young Fur-Traders age 31. He then wrote Ungava and The Coral Island, his best known story, and a lot of other stories besides.)
  • Canadian Crusoes (the first Canadian children’s book of any importance, written by Catharine Parr Traill — similar to early Australian children’s stories)
  • Ivanhoe and other books by Sir Walter Scott were very popular in their day though have fallen out of fashion. But Scott’s work has been as much of an influence as Defoe’s.
  • The works of W.H.G. Kingston, a prolific English writer of boys’ adventure novels.
  • Treasure Island (by Robert Louis Stevenson — inspired by Kingston, and Ballantyne the brave. )

Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island has […] fallen out of favour with present-day readers, but any number of adventure stories, from Rudyard Kipling’s The Jungle Book to The Action Hero’s Handbook derive from it. Stevenson’s young hero, Jim Hawkins, foreshadows the plucky resourcefulness of Anthony Horowitz’s reluctant teenage spy, and Eoin Colfer’s criminal mastermind Artemis Fowl.

Why this is a golden age of children’s literature, Amanda Craig

  • King’s Solomon’s Mines (by Rider Haggard is borderline adult fiction — a triumph of the exotic)
  • Conan Doyle, John Buchan, Anthony Hope, H.G. Wells all wrote for adults but were widely enjoyed by boys.

American

  • Harry Castlemon (prolific but untalented)
  • Oliver Optic (even more prolific and also untalented)
  • Mark Twain (Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn were the first good, true American adventure stories — like Stevenson when writing Treasure Island, Twain didn’t have the slightest interest in reinforcing conventional morality. Twain denied morality but his stories have a lot of moral irony.)
  • Horatio Alger wrote books around the time of the civil war about individuals starting off poor then becoming rich. (Ragged Dick etc.) The “Horatio Alger myth” is the “classic” American success story and character arc, the trajectory from “rags to riches”. An ‘Alger’ story is now a rags-to-riches American story.
  • Thomas L. Janvier wrote The Aztec Tereausre-House. There are strong similarities to King Solomon’s Mines. He then wrote In the Sargasso Sea, which is considered outstanding though neglected by some. His descriptions of setting are magnificent and exotic.

Australian

  • William Howitt lived in Australia for a couple years and wrote A Boy’s Adventures in the Wilds of Australia, which has accurate descriptions of landscape and fauna.
  • Richard Rowe wrote The Boy in the Bush, a set of episodes introducing subjects such as snakes, drought, an old convict, a gold rush. These have been popular subjects in Australian literature.
  • J.H. Hodgetts wrote Tom’s Nugget: a Story of the Australian Goldfields
  • Gordon Stables wrote From Squire to Squatter
  • W.H.G. Kingston wrote stories set in Australia but got the details badly wrong.

 

 

from Written For Children by John Rowe Townsend:

  • The Victorian English speaking world was very much a man’s world.
  • Men dreamt of building a nation or empire, winning wars. (At least those who were the reading classes.)
  • Meanwhile, feminine virtues were: piety, domesticity, sexual submission, repression.
  • Books for boys and girls reflected these attitudes.
  • For boys: life of action on land and at sea
  • For girls: domestic stories
  • Adventure stories overlapped with historical fiction. No clear division.
  • Threesomes are popular in the classic adventure story, each providing a three-cornered contrast to each other.
  • In the Crusoe tradition, there’s a lot of detail about how the main characters manage to stay alive (what they eat and where they sleep etc.)
  • There’s quite a bit of writing about Christian missionaries, and the civilizing effect they have on the local savages.
  • Treasure Island is one of the best written of these stories, and is still good because of its fast pacing (a modern pacing).
  • Long John Silver was a new kind of villain: a villain with something heroic about him. This blurred the black and white good and evil that had been an unwritten rule of children’s literature.
  • American adventure stories have dated even slightly worse than the British ones. Heroes were morally uplifting, unrealistically brave and priggish.
  • These American books tended to reflect a conventional idea of adventure rather than the real thing. Adventure for the Americans was not the same as for the British. To the Victorian British, adventure was something you found overseas, and to do with building an empire.
  • But the great American adventure story was about building America. However, despite the expanding of the Western frontier, there were no excellent adventure children’s books about this published at the time.
  • Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn changed that.
  • In the second half of the 19th C there came a new kind of adventure story: individuals making their own way in life, making good.
  • In these books, the poorest of the poor made their way to the top, becoming rich through hard work.
  • Many writers setting their adventure stories in Australia had seem to never have been here, and often got the details wrong.
  • Like the historical novel, the ‘good gripping yarn’ of high adventure has had a hard time in the post WW2 years. The wide, wide world has shrunk, so trips to the other side of the world are commonplace. The aventure story has suffered more than any other fictional genre from the competition of films and television. (Adventure is visual, and very well suited to the screen.) The downsides of the screen is that the hero is clearly not you — but the main drawcard of the traditional adventure novel was that a young reader could imagine himself (because the protagonists were always boys) as the hero.
  • There wasn’t much in the way of wartime adventure stories right after the wars. The wars offered plenty of real-life adventure of the unwelcome kind. But as the years passed, views on what children could and couldn’t read became less restrictive. Writers now write in an unflinching manner about all sorts of horrible things.