Is this character more ‘flat’ or more ’rounded’?
This distinction was first made by E.M. Forster in Aspects of the Novel. In any work of literature there is a place for characters of both orientations.
- Are by nature 2D and without colour
- Typically have one stand-out trait or none at all
- Are often either ‘good’ or ‘evil’
- Actions are predictable
- Common in formulaic fiction
- The characters in Winnie the Pooh are all flat, but collectively make up parts of a single character (Christopher Robin), who is not flat
- But a flat character is not necessarily artistically worse than a rounded one — whatever serves the story is good.
- More closely approximates a real person
- Possess a number of traits
- We can’t predict their behaviour
- Protagonists aren’t necessarily rounded, though are more likely to be so
- Secondary characters aren’t necessarily flat, though are more likely to be so
- In children’s literature, the rounded characters are generally less complex than they would be in real life, for simplicity’s sake
Dynamic characters change over the course of the story.
Static characters remain the same.
What about the characters in the books you’ve published so far? Here are mine:
Asaf of The Artifacts changes. Therefore he is of ‘dynamic orientation’. He stops collecting material items to make himself happy and begins to broaden his mind with experiences.
Roya of Midnight Feast changes a little, but ultimately chooses to ignore the realities right outside her window. She is closer to the ‘static’ end of the continuum.
Hilda of Hilda Bewildered undergoes an entire character arc from overwhelmed to able to cope.
Allegra of Diary Of A Goth Girl also undergoes an entire character arc, from prickly and mean to loving.
- Both main characters and supporting characters can be static or dynamic.
- Old didactic (moralistic) children’s literature is more likely to have static characters.
- But static characters aren’t necessarily worse than dynamic characters — it depends on the story.
- Contemporary children’s literature commonly depicts inner growth, and therefore needs a dynamic main character.
- Rounded characters can be either dynamic or static — these are two different continua
- There’s kind of a rule of kidlit that a good kid can’t turn evil, but the opposite often happens, even if the ending is left ‘open’, and we’re encouraged to assume redemption
- Oftentimes, if a character were to change too much we’d be disappointed. We’d be disappointed if Anne of Green Gables lost her optimistic attitude, for example.
This distinction is important in children’s fiction.
- Stylisation is a commonly used didactic device. (Stylised characters are used to teach the reader something.)
- A stereotype is a kind of stylisation (as well as tropes and stock characters)
- Contemporary psychological novels tend to feature natural characterization